Too many nursing grads? Two key views

We have a great conversation rolling around the question: Are colleges over supplying nurses? The couple posts we've done are generating comments from Minnesota and across the nation with data and insights.

Please keep it going. We're doing a kind of cool, transparent journalism here as we grope for answers, and your vantage point is crucial. Tell us what you're seeing.

Researchers at Economic Modeling Specialists Inc. also continue to dig into the nurse supply issue with us, providing some great insights.

In this post, we'll highlight two important perspectives from experts who do not believe Minnesota colleges are over supplying nurses.

Jane Foote is executive director of HealthForce Minnesota, a public-private effort to boost the number of health care workers. Adam Suomala is director of member relations for Aging Services of Minnesota, a group that includes assisted living and care centers throughout the state.

"Everybody believes we're still going to be short nurses," said Foote, a former dean of nursing at Minneapolis Community and Technical College.

Looking at the data from our first post on the issue, Foote said, "The numbers don't really match up with what industry is telling us the needs are. We ask our employers that -- 'Are we preparing too many?' Their word to us is, 'Don't stop.'"

She characterized the current supply / demand situation as a "lull before the storm" as health care demands rise and Minnesota's aging nursing workforce begins to retire, although she did mention that one community college is scaling back its nursing enrollment for next fall.

The state's public two-year colleges have seen a huge jump in grads the past few years.

Foote, though, says the nursing programs are not money-makers for the state's community colleges and public funding covers about half the costs.

The challenge, she added, is that there's always a lag time between what employers say they need and the community colleges' ability to increase the flow.

Suomala made some great points in responding to our initial post. He wrote:

To date, the focus on the "right number of nurses" in Minnesota has been almost exclusively around positions in the hospital -- I would encourage you to look at the demographic "boom" of older adults hitting our healthcare system, and the many careers available today in older adult services... specifically skilled care centers, assisted living, and home care.

A common hope of emerging nursing graduates may be a day shift at Children's Hospital, but the reality is where Minnesota needs their service most is in the many expanding arenas serving older adults.

Following up, he laid out for us an array of worries about the growing and extending needs the state will face taking care of its rapidly aging population and how that will fall increasingly on nurses and other health professionals.

State officials, he said, refer to the wave as the "silver tsunami." The aging population will want more home and community-based services that may not be available "without a healthy workforce to do that work. "

Part of the challenge there, however, is convincing nurses to come to senior care, rather than hospitals. There is a pay gap with hospitals generally paying nurses better wages and offering more flexibility.

Suomala told us:

I was recently in a room full of unemployed nurses here in the metro. I asked them to raise their hands if they were looking for jobs in hospitals. They all raised their hands. I asked them who was considering a career in an aging services setting (care center, assisted living or home care, etc.). Only two hands stayed up.

Something simply has to change with the mindset of Minnesota nurses in the opportunities out there for jobs. Today and for tomorrow.

I can understand the frustration of a grad who can't get their dream position working the day shift with babies at Children's Hospital after graduation or living the life TV and film paint with shows like E.R. But that doesn't mean there aren't nursing jobs -- good jobs, rewarding jobs -- all over Minnesota today (and certainly in the future) in the field of aging services.

We're still going to dig into data in future posts about the supply and demand for nurses. But Suomala certainly has me thinking.

Could we end up in a circumstance where the system is oversupplying nurses for hospital jobs while less desirable but still vital nursing jobs go unfilled?

Once again, more questions than answers from us. Help us fill in the gaps.

• Mpls. Fed chief: More inflation could aid economy
• Target solved its payment security issues, but couldn’t solve Canada
• Twin Cities home prices up 10 percent
• Minnesota jobless rate lowest since 2008