Immigration enforcement in Minnesota

Twin Cities churches go to court seeking full details of federal surveillance during ICE ops

Protesters hold signs
U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers stand by as dozens of people protest outside the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building at Fort Snelling, Minn., on Jan. 30.
Ben Hovland | MPR News

Quick Read

The Trump administration had undercover federal agents infiltrate religious and civic organizations during and after the aggressive operation targeting immigrants here last winter. Now, three Twin Cities churches that hosted meetings for the groups want a judge to force the feds to reveal the full extent of its surveillance.

Three Twin Cities churches are asking a judge to order the Trump Administration to reveal the full extent of its surveillance of religious and civic groups during and after last winter’s immigration operation. The undercover activity first came to light this summer in defense filings in a criminal case against 15 anti-ICE activists.

In June, a federal grand jury charged the group with conspiracy to impede or injure federal officers by setting up blockades and staging protests around the Whipple Federal Building. The 94-page indictment does not include evidence that the defendants hurt anyone. The charges are largely based on information that undercover agents gathered while infiltrating Signal chats and meetings of activists.

A batch of documents defense attorneys received from prosecutors as part of the routine discovery process are included in a motion attorney Kevin Riach, who represents lead defendant Isaac Sant, filed on Aug. 13. Riach writes that the initial tranche of materials the Department of Justice handed over omits numerous documents and communications, as well as data from phones and laptops undercover agents used.

The documents revealed so far show Homeland Security Investigations obtained years worth of financial records from labor unions and sent undercover agents to meetings at libraries, parks, union halls and churches as part of efforts that the agency dubbed “Operation Puppet Master” and “Project Whipple Shield.”

Attorney Irina Vaynerman of the nonprofit Groundwork Legal filed a friend-of-the-court brief on Wednesday on behalf of the three churches — First Universalist Church and Hennepin Avenue United Methodist in Minneapolis and St. John the Evangelist Episcopal Church in St. Paul — in support of Riach’s motion for additional discovery.

In an interview with MPR News, Vaynerman said the public deserves to know the full extent of how and why federal agents spied on Minnesotans. She said the surveillance activities carry dark echoes of government spying on Japanese Americans during WWII and on an earlier generation of civil rights activists in the 1960s.

“History does not look fondly on the American government spying on its own people and targeting them for their beliefs and who they are, not what they do,” Vaynerman said. “There’s not criminal activity to justify the wide dragnet of surveillance that occurred here.”

A Hennepin County sheriff’s deputy faces demonstrators
A Hennepin County sheriff’s deputy faces demonstrators during a tense standoff outside the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building on Feb. 7 in Minneapolis. Protesters and law enforcement confronted one another near a fenced perimeter as demonstrators directed chants and symbolic objects toward U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, drawing a heavy police presence at the scene.
Kerem Yücel | MPR News

A spokesperson for the Minnesota U.S. Attorney’s Office declined to comment on the brief. In a Sept. 10 filing, Assistant U.S. Attorney Tory Sailer writes the defendants’ “extraordinarily broad” request for additional information is not necessary for preparing their defense and that additional disclosure about undercover operations could endanger confidential informants and agents.

In her brief, Vaynerman notes that on Dec. 13, 2025, an agent surreptitiously attended a meeting of the Sunrise Movement social justice group at First Universalist. In a report, which is part of the public court file, the agent did not identify any crime but writes that “further attendance was determined to be necessary to rule out violations of law.”

First Universalist Senior Minister Jen Crow said in an interview with MPR News on Wednesday that the revelations have led the church to keep a close eye on unfamiliar people and that some members have stopped attending in person.

“It’s been frightening, both for myself and for members of the community, in particular for folks in our church community who are from any kind of marginalized group. They were already being targeted during the ICE occupation. They’re already at greater risk,” Crow said.

She also said that on Jan. 10, agents “openly surveilled” the church from the outside, repeatedly circling the block during a memorial service for a church member.

“It would be nice to have the full discovery and be able to see how often the government was here, what they were looking for and to have an honest record of their behavior for this period of time,” Crow said.

In late February, Homeland Security Investigations agents followed Emmett Doyle, who was later charged in the Minnesota 15 case, to Hennepin Avenue United Methodist and observed him loading “ICE Out” signs into a truck. In mid-April, an undercover agent attended a meeting of the group Direct Action Minnesota at St. John’s and ran the license plates of people parked outside.

Federal prosecutors allege Direct Action Minnesota is an “antifa affinity group.” They filed the charges after President Donald Trump in issued a national security memorandum known as NSPM-7 in September 2025 targeting people he called “anarchists and agitators.”

Friend-of-the court briefs, also known as amicus briefs, are rare in criminal cases, but this is the second filed in support of Riach’s discovery motion.

In August, three conservative and libertarian-leaning organizations — the Cato Institute, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression and the Society for the Rule of Law — filed a similar brief.

The groups argue the surveillance and prosecution are “designed to chill participation in protest activity, quell dissent and silence critics of Trump administration policies under the guise of combating terrorism.”