In ‘The Savage Mind,’ Ojibwe author David Treuer connects modern violence to America’s frontier legacy

Go Deeper.
Create an account or log in to save stories.
Like this?
Thanks for liking this story! We have added it to a list of your favorite stories.
Quick Read
Ojibwe author David Treuer doesn’t usually get nervous doing book readings. But as he kicked off a recent event at Four Pines Bookstore in Bemidji, he said there’s one exception.
“I only get really nervous reading to family, and since I'm nervous, that must mean that you're all family,” he said. “So thanks for coming out. I'm really excited.”
Treuer grew up on the nearby Leech Lake reservation, and several relatives were in attendance. But there were also the more metaphorical family who are part of the area he once called home.
“You can't fool your family. And like I can fool strangers, no problem,” he quipped.
Turn Up Your Support
MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all.
He was there to read from his eighth book, “The Savage Mind: An American Legacy.”
Treuer said the origin of the book itself started in 2015 during a moment of personal crisis following an officer shooting in San Bernardino, Calif., down the road from where he was living with his children. Fourteen people were killed that day.

“For reasons I didn't really understand, I was really, really afraid, afraid for my kids, who were sleeping, all three of them, and I was afraid for myself as the person who was supposed to protect them,” Treuer said. “And I was deeply afraid for the country, which really seemed to be tearing itself apart.”
Treuer said he was also affected by the police killing of 12-year-old Tamir Rice in Cleveland, roughly a year earlier.
To deal with his fear, Treuer sat down and began writing his kids a letter to try and move from feelings to thought, and from pure emotion to perspective and understanding.
And as he processed those feelings, he also had to sort through his own parents’ experiences as Americans.
“My mom was a Leech Laker. She grew up in conditions I can't properly imagine in terms of poverty and neglect, and for her, this country was poised to take, and it would always do its worst,” Treuer said. “So she had to armor herself.”
He said one way his mother armored herself was by going to law school. She became the first female Native American attorney in Minnesota, and went on to become the first Native American woman to serve as a judge in the U.S.

Despite her success, Treuer said his mother’s feeling persisted that the country would always do its worst. “Her disposition didn't change really, that was her version of this place, and she had every reason to feel that way. And she wasn't wrong,” he said.
Treuer said his father’s relationship with the country was quite different. As an Austrian Jewish Holocaust survivor, his father fled Europe for the safety of the U.S. Treuer emphasized his father was not naive nor a Pollyanna.
“In his own words, he said, ‘Yeah, this country saved my life. No one else wanted me. Everyone else tried to kill me. But this country saved my life.’ And he wasn't wrong either,” Treuer said. “I kind of tell the story of America's schizophrenia, if you will. Like, it is a place that will try to do its worst to my mom and it's a place where my father did find refuge.”
A fresh take on history
Treuer’s 2019 nonfiction book “The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee” garnered national acclaim for challenging a narrative popularized by writer Dee Brown that the Native American way of life more or less ended in 1890 with the Wounded Knee Massacre.
Treuer’s counternarrative earned his book a spot on the New York Times Best Sellers list, as well as distinction as a National Book Award finalist. Among other accolades, in his home state, Treuer’s book also won the Minnesota Book Prize.
His new book also puts a new frame around historical events.

The mass shooting in California and the killing of Tamir Rice drove Treuer to start the book. But as he worked on it, other high-profile acts of violence would unfold.
They included the killing of Philando Castile by police in Falcon Heights in 2016, the Harvest Festival mass shooting in Las Vegas in 2017, and the shooting death of Ahmaud Arbery by white men while he was jogging through a neighborhood in Georgia in 2020.
Then there was George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis in 2020 at the hands of police.
Rice, Castile, Arbery and Floyd were all Black. And Treuer said all of their deaths led to more feelings of fear.
“I thought and I read and I studied and I kept writing this long letter to my kids, and it became clear to me that the thing that lurked behind all this stuff was violence, not any old kind of violence, but frontier violence,” Treuer said. “That is America's original sin: the theft of Native land and the theft and destruction of Black and brown bodies, and the theft of immigrant labor.”
Treuer argues that we’re taught in school that the frontier ended with the close of the Plains Wars in 1890. But in his book he challenges that assertion.
Instead, Truer contends, the frontier kept going like a wave until it reached the Pacific Coast. Then it broke into two directions.
One was overseas with the frontier living on through American imperial policy.
“America invaded Cuba and Puerto Rico and Hawaii and the Philippines all within the next decade, and it's ongoing,” Treuer said. “Then Korea, Vietnam.”
Treuer argues that the U.S. support of Israel, which he sees treating Palestinians in the same way the U.S. treated Native American people, as another iteration of the overseas spread of the frontier mindset.

Treuer said the second wave broke backwards into American culture, “into all of our hearts and minds, and is expressed and reexpressed and staged and restaged in all sorts of public rituals of violence.” He said George Floyd’s murder, Columbine, and all the other school shootings that followed are examples of those public rituals of violence.
“I came to see all these things as expressions of that initial violence, but the frontier isn't out there. The frontier is inside of all of us, as Americans,” Treuer said. “That's what I mean by the savage mind.”
When reflecting on his book, Treuer noted it’s the shortest one in his opus, and he said it was the hardest to write.
“It was not fun to write. It felt urgent. It felt a little bit life or death, in a way, to do it. So, and now it's done, and I'm going to go back to fiction happily,” he said. “No more nonfiction ever again.”
One of the audience members at Treuer’s book reading in Bemidji was Alena Hrabcakova. She’s a psychotherapist and art therapist who said she worked at Red Lake High School at the time of a school shooting in 2005. Having read Treuer’s new book twice since its release in early October, Hrabkova said she highly recommends it for historical context.
“I feel like David brought up a great summary of all the wars in America, what is also happening in Gaza and around the world, and what has perpetrated this savage mind, this violence that we see in America and abroad, but specifically on the frontier, with colonization, assimilation, and what we did to the Indigenous peoples,” she said. “But also how it affected Indian communities and how they treated one another due to all this trauma. It's a must-read.”
Hrabkova added that while Treuer wrote the book as a love letter to his children, “You also realize when you're reading it, it's almost like you're his child too, and he's writing it to you.”
Treuer will be at Wóyute Thipi at 5 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23 in Minneapolis to discuss “The Savage Mind” with James Beard award-winning chef Sean Sherman. It will be hosted by Alaskan Native Tlingit journalist Kate Nelson.

