State utility regulators scold Xcel executives, order audit amid surging billing complaints

Go Deeper.
Create an account or log in to save stories.
Like this?
Thanks for liking this story! We have added it to a list of your favorite stories.
Quick Read
State utility regulators chastised the state’s largest electricity provider, Xcel Energy, Thursday for failing to adequately respond to years of escalating customer service complaints. They also ordered the utility to undergo a third-party audit of its billing and customer service practices.
The ruling from the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission followed an investigation the PUC launched last year into Xcel’s billing practices following a sharp increase in complaints about billing errors over the past four years.
The commission fielded dozens of complaints submitted by individuals, businesses, schools, churches and even cities. Many described difficulty setting up affordable payment plans. Several involved unpaid credits for solar panels that customers installed. Cities reported staff having to log long hours trying to resolve billing disputes.
"This has been a pervasive problem.” said Commissioner Audrey Partridge. “We've seen much higher customer complaints starting in 2023, and they have continued to be extremely high going forward since that point. The company has had years to address this and has not done so."
Turn Up Your Support
MPR News helps you turn down the noise and build shared understanding. Turn up your support for this public resource and keep trusted journalism accessible to all.
At the hearing, Partridge played a recording of a customer service call between an Xcel customer service representative and a PUC mediator who was helping an Xcel customer try to work out a payment plan with the utility.

“She had a recent death in her family, and it's affected her income,” the mediator explained. “She can pay $300 today, and then a total of $300 each month. Is that something that you can adjust for her?"
"No,” the agent replied. “That won't work."
Eventually, the Xcel representative called a supervisor, who suggested it likely wasn’t a PUC advocate on the line, but someone impersonating one.
"They usually don't call us for that. I think it's probably a friend acting like one."
The call ended with Xcel refusing to adjust the payment plan.
"That is a prime example of what goes into the complaints for billing and credit,” said Partridge.
“They are not being treated in line with what we expect and with what you are obligated to do for folks."
Matthew Chad, senior director of Xcel’s customer care division, apologized for how its employees handled the call.
"Every customer deserves respectful treatment and accurate information. We did not meet that standard on this call, and we own that,” Chad said, adding that Xcel is working to address billing errors and customer service complaints.
"We are not here to minimize or shift any responsibility,” Chad said. “Where we have fallen short, we will fix it."
A range of complaints
Many Xcel customers who fell behind on their bills reported difficulty setting up an affordable payment plan. Others say they received incorrect information from customer service representatives. Some said it took months, or even years, to resolve billing issues.
"There are multiple commenters in the record who have said that they think Xcel owes them hundreds or even thousands of dollars, but they've just given up because it was in their mind so impossible to navigate,” said Annie Levenson-Falk, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota.
Many businesses, churches and schools reported billing delays and said they were not properly credited for installing solar energy projects.

Several cities also reported problems, saying staff often had to spend many extra hours resolving issues.
“We've experienced things such as incorrect bills, misapplied payments or credits, some delayed billing,” said Nick Stumo-Langer, assistant mayor for housing, economic vibrancy and infrastructure for the city of St. Paul.
“And to Excel's credit, when we've contacted them, the customer service staff have always been very helpful. But these issues have existed for many months and years in some cases.”
Xcel says it has improved billing processes, reduced backlogs and made substantial progress resolving solar program issues. It’s also given additional training to customer service representatives.
Xcel Principal Attorney Chethana Perera told commissioners the utility has worked hard to address the issues they have raised.
“We have been doing our best to address shortcomings,” Perera said. “We do think we’ve made a good amount of progress, bringing complaint numbers down from year to year."
Outside review
Xcel asked the PUC to let the utility do its own internal review. But commissioners said the utility has had plenty of time to fix its problems.
Commissioner Partridge said Xcel needs to take customer service and billing issues more seriously, mentioning the utility's CEO by name.
"This is the core of your business,” Partridge said. “Bob Frenzel himself should be in this room, understanding that this is the basics of the utility business. There has not been enough attention from your leadership to fix this. Since 2023, we've seen sky-high complaints. It's 2026. If you haven't hired somebody to fix this, then you've missed the boat."
Other commissioners wondered whether the compensation of Xcel’s top-level management was tied to customer service metrics.
“To me, this is a systematic problem,” said Commissioner Hwikwon Ham. “That systematic problem doesn’t get solved unless your CEO has some negative impact from this.”
Electric utilities in Minnesota are protected monopolies regulated by the PUC. They have a protected service area and customer base and a guaranteed rate of return.
“But the tradeoff is you need to treat your customers well,” said Commissioner John Tuma. “They’re captive. They must be treated with respect. It’s a public utility, it’s a public service.
You’re to provide affordable, reasonable, adequate service to the people of Minnesota. We’re seeing failure in that area.”
The commission unanimously approved an independent audit to be overseen by the Minnesota Department of Commerce and paid for by Xcel. The final report is expected by the end of 2027.
In a statement, Xcel promised to deliver clear and accurate bills, as well as responsive and empathetic customer service.
And the power company acknowledged it had more work to do. “We heard the Commission and will collaborate closely with the third-party auditor on ways to improve,” the statement said.
